what's up bbc?
Last October the BBC announced that it would be responding to budget shortfalls with severe layoffs and programming cuts. According to their PR, online products would be hardest hit, though they would strive to cut volume before quality.
With today's posting of Mystery image of 'life on Mars', the BBC has officially failed this goal. C'mon, BBC, quoting some nutjob's theory that a Martian rock formation is a statue "obviously built by an ancient civilisation that later departed Mars and settled Denmark", and then attributing it to "Madurobob" on "the internet" isn't quite journalism. Actually, it isn't anywhere near journalism. What isn't quite journalism is Web worries after suicide spate.
The nutjob in this story is an MP blaming the internet for an uptick in suicides. Now it is an MP (and not some screen name off the internet) with the nutty theory, so even though the theory is nutty, the BBC has a legitimate reason, or maybe even an obligation, to publish it. As a voter, I believe that when CNN learns Dennis Kucinich believes he saw a UFO, they have an obligation to tell me. The news is that Kucinich or the MP or whomever believes the nutty theory--the theory itself should be treated with some incredulity.
This MP seems to have formed her opinion completely without evidence. There's a bunch of suicides. There's an internet. Surely they're related. Even though local law enforcement says that "while some of the seven young people knew each other, there was nothing to link them all," and that even this gives no indication that the ones that did know each other knew each other from the internet. Later in the story it is revealed that some of the boys knew each other--from school. The MP neither seems to acknowledge the well-established phenomenon of suicide contagion, nor does she seem worried that the schools could be the cause of the uptick. She fusses that "memorial walls" on social networking sites romanticize suicide, but doesn't seem to make the connection that these internet "memorial walls" are just reflections of the real-life memorials that spring up after all well-publicized tragedies. Clearly this is just another case of a public figure pointing the finger at society's latest Big Bad: Big Bad wolf, Big Bad rock-n-roll, Big Bad MTV--all have given way to Big Bad internet (and Big Bad video games played on the Big Bad internet). And while the BBC shouldn't be held responsible for the MP's crappy reasoning skills, they should have made the same observations I just did.
With today's posting of Mystery image of 'life on Mars', the BBC has officially failed this goal. C'mon, BBC, quoting some nutjob's theory that a Martian rock formation is a statue "obviously built by an ancient civilisation that later departed Mars and settled Denmark", and then attributing it to "Madurobob" on "the internet" isn't quite journalism. Actually, it isn't anywhere near journalism. What isn't quite journalism is Web worries after suicide spate.
The nutjob in this story is an MP blaming the internet for an uptick in suicides. Now it is an MP (and not some screen name off the internet) with the nutty theory, so even though the theory is nutty, the BBC has a legitimate reason, or maybe even an obligation, to publish it. As a voter, I believe that when CNN learns Dennis Kucinich believes he saw a UFO, they have an obligation to tell me. The news is that Kucinich or the MP or whomever believes the nutty theory--the theory itself should be treated with some incredulity.
This MP seems to have formed her opinion completely without evidence. There's a bunch of suicides. There's an internet. Surely they're related. Even though local law enforcement says that "while some of the seven young people knew each other, there was nothing to link them all," and that even this gives no indication that the ones that did know each other knew each other from the internet. Later in the story it is revealed that some of the boys knew each other--from school. The MP neither seems to acknowledge the well-established phenomenon of suicide contagion, nor does she seem worried that the schools could be the cause of the uptick. She fusses that "memorial walls" on social networking sites romanticize suicide, but doesn't seem to make the connection that these internet "memorial walls" are just reflections of the real-life memorials that spring up after all well-publicized tragedies. Clearly this is just another case of a public figure pointing the finger at society's latest Big Bad: Big Bad wolf, Big Bad rock-n-roll, Big Bad MTV--all have given way to Big Bad internet (and Big Bad video games played on the Big Bad internet). And while the BBC shouldn't be held responsible for the MP's crappy reasoning skills, they should have made the same observations I just did.